66% of marketers want outcome-based fees. Why are we still selling hours?
By Mahesh Murthy·Founder, Pinstorm·Published 18 November 2026
The short answer
A Google–BCG survey earlier this year asked marketers how they would prefer to pay partners. Some 66 per cent put outcome-based or performance-linked fees as their top choice. Fixed fees and retainers attracted only 26 per cent.
Clients want a connection between what they pay and what they get. Duh.
Meanwhile, WPP chief executive Cindy Rose responded “I suspect it will take a few years.”
The gap between what clients want and what they sign on for is worth looking at. To understand it, go where the money is.
There are basically four ways to pay an agency.
Commission rewards spending. The more media you buy, the more the agency earns. That creates an awkward incentive: your agency can make more money by making your ads and media buys less effective and hence more expensive.
Hourly fees reward time taken. The longer the job takes, the bigger the invoice. Efficiency can become a financial disadvantage. You can do it in 4 hours? Please don't, take 20.
Output fees reward on-time delivery: a film, a campaign, thirty social posts. You know what you are getting, but not how good it is. No one questions your brief, your strategy. You get what you pay for, and it's likely not what you need.
Outcome-linked fees reward a result. Some or all of the agency’s compensation depends on what its work achieves.
These models can coexist. But they reward very different behaviors.
At Pinstorm, we don’t like really working on retainers, commissions or project fees. We prefer compensation tied to outcomes. Or a hybrid with a fixed plus variable.
That changes what we pay attention to, what we optimize for, and what we are willing to say when a client’s brief is bad.
An hourly model will happily pay us to execute a bad brief. An outcome model gives us a financial reason to challenge it.
But there are real problems. Pretending otherwise would make this post just another agency sales pitch.
The first is measurement. You cannot price an outcome you cannot jointly measure.
A sale attributed to a paid search click on Monday may have been caused by a television ad on Friday, a dinner-party conversation on Saturday, and a competitor running out of stock on Sunday.
The click gets the credit. That doen't mean it did all the work.
The second is control. If the client’s sales team cannot close, or if the product is unavailable, or if the website checkout doesn’t work, tying your entire fee to sales makes you the insurer of somebody else’s incompetence. That's not confidence, it's stupidity.
The third is the agency’s economics. Salaries arrive every month. Results do not.
A large agency cannot randomly replace predictable fees with uncertain income while keeping costs unchanged. Especially the large, public-listed ones. The same way, a client cannot reasonably demand that an agency carry every risk while offering it a tightly-capped upside.
This is why a hybrid arrangement can make sense. A delivery fee plus a meaningful bonus for incremental business results is still outcome-linked compensation. A bonus for delivering thirty posts on time is not.
Clients have special responsibilities here. Wanting accountability while withholding the data needed to measure it is a special kind of procurement hell.
At Pinstorm, we prefer to have this uncomfortable conversation upfront. What are we trying to change? What can our work reasonably influence? What would justify us earning a bonus or a share of revenue?
Clicks and impressions can help explain performance. They are not, by themselves, evidence that the business has grown.
A confession: we don’t always get this right. Measurement is imperfect, and sometimes our work sucks. But when it does, we correct it at our cost. That is basic accountability.
Linking compensation to results requires going further and agreeing to what financial consequences follow success or failure.
The lady from WPP may be right about the pace of widespread adoption. But “it will takes time” should come with an understanding of what will make it happen faster. Better measurement? Better access to data? A fairer division of risk?
Or yet another year of timesheets?
When a client asks “What did my money achieve?” and the agency answers “Here’s how many hours we worked,” you have a square peg in a round hole.
And the client is getting billed for the hammering.
Want to understand the model behind these beliefs? Read: What is outcome-based marketing?

